John Locke Triangle
Triangle Home

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

The Duke lacrosse press conferences

Posted April 11th, 2007 at 5:46 PM by Jon Ham

I just got back from Attorney General Roy Cooper’s press conference and also the press conference held by the attorneys for Reade Seligmann, Collin Finnerty and Dave Evans. I’ll have a video up later tonight and a couple of photos, but I had a few observations before I head home from the office.

1) The biggest losers today are Durham DA Mike Nifong, The Herald-Sun and the City of Durham. Nifong, for obvious reasons, is in big trouble. But Seligmann attorney Jim Cooney took special pains to single out the cowardice of The Herald-Sun, a newspaper where I spent 19 years as an editor. If the hometown paper had just once pointed to Nifong’s abuse of process, Cooney said, all of this might have been avoided. But they didn’t, to their everlasting shame. I’ve said before that if the previous regime — pre-Paxton Media — had been in charge, we would not have abandoned our duty as the public watchdog the way the Paxton-led Herald-Sun did. And also, Durham. Durham came off as a Third World cesspool of corruption today. First, the state’s attorney general blasted the district attorney in the strongest terms. Then Evans attorney Joe Cheshire and Cooney both cited the lack of professionalism among Durham’s police and DA’s office, and also the behavior of so-called “community activists,” white and black, who fanned the flames of racial hatred for political ends. Durham should hang its head in shame tonight.

2) The media took a beating. All of the lawyers made clear that it was the media nationally, like The Herald-Sun locally (and, I might add, The News & Observer, which is certainly not without fault), that ignored the facts for what they thought was a better story: rich, white lacrosse players rape poor black mother just trying to make her way through college. It was always a crock, and now they know it. Cheshire pointed out their sins to them in person today. Katie Couric, Harry Smith and Greta Van Susteren were there to hear it first-hand. It was wonderful to see.

Also, Roy Cooper. Well, he got a lot of people’s votes today. His statement was much stronger than I had ever hoped. He came through with what Cheshire called a “crystal clear and powerful” statement that proclaimed the innocence of the three players in explicit terms. It was a masterful performance and each lawyer and each player pointed that out.

Another impression: These three guys are incredibly smart and eloquent. As Cooney said, you only had to spend 10 minutes with any one of them to know they weren’t capable of the crimes that Crystal Gail Mangum (yes, that’s her name) accused them of. Their statements were wonderfully crafted, not vindictive, and were pointed toward the future.

As I said, I’ll have video later and a photo or two.

UPDATE: Photos have been added above. Also, here are links to PDFs of Cooper’s statement and the dismissal orders for Reade, Collin and Dave.

4 Responses to “The Duke lacrosse press conferences”

  1. Jon Sanders Says:

    I’d like to predict that the Left is not going to let this case go so easily. I would not be the least surprised if some of the Gang of 88 and their fellow-travelers don’t try to put the focus back on the lacrosse team — well, they might not be guilty of rape, but they did shout the “n-word” and are still therefore examples of “violent rich white athletic male privilege.”

    I hope I’m wrong.

  2. Jeff A. Taylor Says:

    Jonx2:

    Watch the NY Times. By rights, Cooper’s statement and finding should be A1 material. If it is played there and reported straight — ie as damning indictment of Nifong and the pot-bangers — then I think all but the truly loony Left has to let it go.

    Also, check out Brodhead:

    “Let’s be clear about what was said today. The Attorney General did not dismiss the allegations on narrow, equivocal or legalistic grounds. He determined our students to be innocent of the charges and said they were “the tragic result of a rush to accuse.” In short, he used the strongest language of vindication. … As for Duke, while not reliving the past year, we won’t be afraid to go back and learn what we can from this difficult experience. … During the past year, the world has known these young men, their teammates and a great university largely through the filter of unproven allegations. I trust that today’s decision will begin a new day for all involved.”

    Who is that guy and where has he been the last 13 months? Last I heard from Dick, Crystal Gail had an absolute right to hear her “unproven allegations” floated in a court of law with 30-year prison terms in the balance.

    http://www.newsobserver.com/1185/story/562932-p2.html

  3. La Shawn Barber's Corner Says:

    All Charges Dropped in Duke Lacrosse Case – Players ‘Innocent’ Says AG

    Thursday, April 12: It’s nice to be acknowledged by writers like Michael Barone (met him last year at CPAC). I haven’t done nearly as much as bloggers like KC Johnson, but I’m glad I did something. Instead of writing more about the…

  4. Right Angles » Blog Archive » Hey hey, ho ho, their racist hate they can’t let go! Says:

    [...] How about advocating for the victims for once? (I told you that some people wouldn’t let this case go so easily.) [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

© 2010 John Locke Foundation | 200 West Morgan St., Raleigh, NC 27601, Voice: (919) 828-3876
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use